Kenneth (kensmind) wrote in potus_geeks,

  • Location:
  • Mood:
  • Music:

Book Review: Collision 2012 - Obama vs. Romney and the Future of Elections in America

Readers who are wishing for an unbiased, non-slanted retelling of the story of the 2012 US Presidential election will find what they wish for in Dan Balz' fair and thorough offering Collision 2012: Obama vs. Romney and the Future of Elections in America.


The book is broken into three sections entitled The Pivot, The Republicans and The Choice. Two things are especially delightful about this book: (1) The author gets much of the story straight from the horses' mouths. Most of the candidates for the GOP nomination and many who decided not to run meet with the author for extensive interviews and many of the conclusions that Balz comes to are ones that the subjects of his book do not take issue with. An entire chapter near the end of the book is devoted to a post-election interview that the author has at Mitt Romney's home and it is quite insightful in itself. (2) The author refrains from making political judgements that conclude that any party or candidate is good or bad. He is very respectful of all of the candidates, in the style of a Walter Cronkite or some other iconic plugged-in professional. That's not to suggest that he doesn't make any judgements, quite the contrary. Balz is quick to criticize many of the strategies employed by both campaigns and is fair in his criticism. This is best shown by the fact that the candidates and campaign staff that he interviews do not take exception to any of his characterizations. He is also quick to explain many of the perplexing decisions facing the candidates and their campaigns, giving the reader an understanding of why they did what they did or didn't do.

The section on the race for the Republican nomination is especially interesting. Balz spends a chapter on almost every candidate who was leading the race at one time, and provides a well-reasoned analysis of why each of their campaigns rose and fell. In his interview with Romney he asks many of the tough questions and in doing so, provides an excellent example of how a journalist can ask probing questions, while remaining respectful and objective.

For those of us who were hoping for an even-handed, professional, objective and unbiased history of the 2012 election, but thought such a creature to be mythical, prepare to be pleasantly surprised. This is an excellent book for the political junkie, for historians, and for all who still believe that political differences can be looked at without emotional rancor. It will be hard to top this book to find a better chronicle of the 2012 election.
Tags: 2012 election, barack obama, book review, mitt romney, presidential bios

Recent Posts from This Community

  • Post a new comment


    Comments allowed for members only

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded