Kenneth (kensmind) wrote in potus_geeks,
Kenneth
kensmind
potus_geeks

  • Location:
  • Mood:
  • Music:

Book Review: The Man Who Saved the Union-Ulysses Grant in War and Peace

H. W. Brands, who has previously written wonderful biographies of Presidents Theodore Roosevelt, Andrew Jackson and Franklin Roosevelt, brings that same professionalism and thoroughness to his latest book The Man Who Saved the Union: Ulysses Grant in War and Peace. Grant presents as a challenging subject, having being doubly distinguished, first as a soldier and then as president, such that telling his story is difficult even in 637 pages. But Brands excels in doing so, first taking the reader through his subject's early life, then into his civil war career, next to his postbellum career as a general, then as president through the difficult period of reconstruction, and finally to Grant's life following the presidency, including his final battle: a race against the grim reaper to conclude his memoirs and provide for his family before a painful cancer takes his life.

BrandsBook

Few writers can make history as clear, coherent and interesting as Brands, and he does a masterful job of not only telling us about Grant's doings, but also of putting them in the context of the times he lived in. For example, in the section on Grant's civil war career, we are given well-explained accounts of Grant's battle plans, but are also told of what is occurring elsewhere in the war, giving the reader a greater appreciation of the significance of Grant's accomplishments.

The book takes us from Grants early years, through his fortuitous entry into West Point, his marginal success as a cadet, his exploits as a young lieutenant in the Mexican War, his lean years of disappointing his father and struggling financially, his rise to the primary military leadership role in the civil war, his conduct of the war including his relationship with Abraham Lincoln and the second-guessing he endured as commander from many different sources. We are taken through the period of Lincoln's assassination, the turbulent presidency of Andrew Johnson, the move to draft Grant as president, his struggles as president to protect the rights of freedmen in the south, his battles with the Ku Klux Klan and the constant challenge of reconstruction. Brands gives a wonderful account of Grant's round-the-world tour after the end of his presidency, the failed attempt to draft Grant for a third term as chief executive, and Grant's very principled efforts to repay investors who were swindled by his son's unscrupulous business partner. The book concludes with Grant's battle with throat cancer and his courageous struggle to write his autobiography in the midst of a most painful illness in order to provide for his family.



Brands does not shy away from the subject of Grant's problems with alcohol, but makes the argument that this issue was probably exaggerated and that there is no evidence that Grant's drinking ever affected his leadership or his decision-making. If there is one criticism of the book, it may be that the scandals which plagued Grant's second term as president are not sufficiently addressed. One might conclude that the author has become sufficiently enamored with his subject so as to drift into hero-worship. But Brands articulates a strong case for why his adulation of his subject is justified, and how subsequent criticisms of Grant may be rooted more in the politics of the day than in fairness. It is hard to doubt, after reading this book, that Grant was very principled, committed to the concept of equal rights as well as many other causes for the betterment of his nation.

2012 has produced many wonderful biographies, but this may be the best of the bunch.
Tags: abraham lincoln, andrew johnson, book review, presidential bios, ulysses s. grant
Subscribe

  • Happy Thanksgiving from Potus Geeks

    Happy Thanksgiving everyone. This is a holiday in which many Presidents have been a part of, from Washington to Biden. In fact even before there was…

  • Presidential Transitions: 1920

    I'm reading the new book by Christopher Cox entitled Woodrow Wilson: The Light Withdrawn (review soon to follow), and it is awful to read what a…

  • Presidential Transitions: 1952

    In the 1952 presidential election, Republicans sought to end 20 years of having a Democrat in the White House. The nation had stuck with Franklin…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Comments allowed for members only

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 5 comments